跳至網頁內容

GE1129 Creative Photography

評核項目
  • 不設考試
  • 不設小測
  • 設有個人報告
  • 設有小組研習
開辦學期
2018/19 Sem B 2017/18 Summer 2017/18 Sem B 2016/17 Sem B 2015/16 Summer 2015/16 Sem B 2015/16 Sem A 2014/15 Sem B 2014/15 Sem A 2013/14 Summer
平均工作量
A+ (1)
A (6)
A- (2)
B+ (2)
B (8)
B- (5)
C+ (6)
C (0)
C- (0)
D (0)
Fail (0)
Dropped (0)

30 則留言 撰寫留言

2018/19 Sem B

B-

平時冇玩開影相,但都有B range,Lecturer幾好人,但比分就好手緊,我D Assignment,都好俾心機做,但都係得B-. 有Frd玩開影相都係得B,所以都收貨。最後搵個真係影相超Pro嘅人一齊,唔係就唔好reg

2018/19 Sem B

B-

Phil哥上堂笑keh keh,比Grade放毒蛇。利申:有影開相,可能我個Style,唔啱身為藝術家嘅佢。唔建議Reg,除非你係佢杯茶。

2018/19 Sem B

C+

This course is a easy course, 4 assignments in total, each contribute 25%. Because I don’t have a pro camera, so I used my phone to take the pictures instead. As a result, the comment given by Phil was like a piece of shxt. Anyway, I got a C+. Reg this course!!!!! If u wanna be a pro photographer.!!!

2018/19 Sem B

C+

Workload少,上堂輕鬆,Lecturer係個對影相好有要求嘅人。成個course得4份 Asm,Phil比分都幾嚴。可能我影嘅相唔合佢口味,所以成績

2018/19 Sem B

B

認真對Photography有興趣或者有玩開先好reg。上堂好輕鬆,Phil都幾nice,成個course4份功課。每份都係要影相。所以真心真心真心影相有料先好reg.

2018/19 Sem B

B

首先對住phil呢啲藝術家脾氣Professor,影出嚟嘅作品其實好難對中佢口味,好難捉摸,四份功課又要唔同主題,要做好多research,其實花咗好多時間,即使影開相,如果同concept唔係扣得好深,已經會扣分。而且phil會偏心,如果你上堂唔係好active,令佢冇記住你,其實好難話有靚grade!攞B雖然未到最差,但實際上花咗好多時間,好大機會拉低左其他course嘅grade。

2018/19 Sem B

A

功課有4份:
1)Portrait 2)Decisive Moment 3)Landscape 4)Photo Series

前3份交1張相,最後一份就係10張以內。前三份當然可以交多過一張相俾佢睇,但係佢只會為其中一張(你自己揀一張)評分,同埋每一份功課都要寫Artist Statement講解下你份作品。所以其實workload大唔大係睇你自己。你可以試好多attempt,影到自己滿意為止,亦可以求求其其。我自己就因為暑假淨讀佢,所以真係用左好多時間周圍影同埋影自己嘅Self Portrait。

上堂主要介紹世界各地從古到今有特色有影響力嘅攝影師。欣賞作品,睇紀錄佢哋創作過程嘅影片等等。Phil非常搞笑,整日搞爛gag,所以上堂唔會悶。(坐前D,佢會記住你,問你問題,對你好友好,睇你鐘唔鐘意同佢互動啦,佢超級歡迎。)

我建議你如果有影開相有作品(為執嘅都可以俾佢睇),可以落堂就俾佢睇下評論下,咁你都可以趁機get下佢鐘意咩樣嘅功課。同埋佢上堂教嘅攝影師嘅特色你可以學左佢,模仿下。如果妳Artist Statement有寫俾邊個攝影師inspired應該佢會好鍾意。覺得你好有思想。堂上亦都有好壞學生作品分享,唔想同佢傾計嘅同學仔都唔洗驚毫無頭緒。

我覺得本身對美sensitive或者好有想法好有性格好多情感嘅人會比較得心應手,因為你好容易catch到佢教嘅artist嘅作品嘅亮點並且用落自己到。而起黎方面經驗唔多嘅同學仔我都好推薦黎嘅course,D攝影師我覺得最重要唔係咩技巧(technical都重要嘅)我個人覺得最inspiring係佢哋背後嘅motif。睇佢哋嘅作品你可以見到好多唔同視覺嘅世界,可能佢哋嘅觀點會刺激到你思考,開發你個腦未掂過嘅領域哈哈哈。係一個好好玩嘅course。

2017/18 Sem B

A

好啦講返平時上堂嘅野,平時上佢堂係好輕鬆同好笑嘅,佢啲笑話收收埋埋應該都夠開場棟篤笑。
功課方面只係得四份姐,對於影開相嘅我嚟講唔係好難。雖然上堂輕鬆但唔好諗住咁就可以hea佢,佢對相係有要求嘅,如果唔識影相或者諗住hea嘅真係唔好㨂啦,唔好交啲垃圾相強姦佢對眼。
如果想交流可以揾我tg/ig/snapchat: alan_lawkh
.
石sir個page: https://philshek.com/
石sir ig: https://www.instagram.com/philshek/
石sir Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/phil.shek

2017/18 Sem B

A

semB嗰陣waiting list勁多人排緊呢科,所以我有日等佢落堂嗰陣就去咗揾佢問佢可唔可以批多個位比我。結果入到去嗰陣佢自己一個人好寂莫咁喺度播緊歌,而咁啱我又記得首歌個名叫做Libertango,所以就走埋去同佢搭散,佢好surprised估唔到會有學生會識呢首歌仲同我傾咗陣,傾完音樂之後我再同佢講返話我想讀佢呢科但係冇位,佢聽完笑咗聲就話肯開多個位比我

2017/18 Summer

A

2018 2019semB嗰陣waiting list勁多人排緊呢科,所以我有日等佢落堂嗰陣就去咗揾佢問佢可唔可以批多個位比我。結果入到去嗰陣佢自己一個人好寂莫咁喺度播緊歌,而咁啱我又記得首歌個名叫做Libertango,所以就走埋去同佢搭散,佢好surprised估唔到會有學生會識呢首歌仲同我傾咗陣,傾完音樂之後我再同佢講返話我想讀佢呢科但係冇位,佢聽完笑咗聲就話肯開多個位比我

2016/17 Sem B

B

If you like photography, his lectures are interesting, but he focuses on portrait photography and does little landscape photography. Better to follow want he wants than have your own style.
The grade is very subjective. Imagine a motion-blurred photo getting an A and another photo he praised a lot getting only B, not sure how he grades photos as his only comment is "wow". I think even NatGeo's Kelvin Yuen cannot get A in this course.

2015/16 Summer

A-

建議有玩開相機 影開相先好TAKE

上堂其實幾輕鬆
不過有時會講D出名既攝影師既歷史 播下片咁 有DD悶
有時就會拎D相出黎講下 對影相都幾有啟發

5個ASSIGNMENT全部都係交唔同TOPIC既相
1個GP PJ係要搵相出黎評好壞

我本身影相都唔算好叻 玩左2-3年相機
以為頂多得B RANGE
完全無同呀SIR獨立溝通過 佢唔認得我 亦都走過一兩堂
但上堂係要TAKE ATTENDANCE既

2015/16 Sem B

C+

he is a weird but nice person
it is a very subjective course spoken by himself
you never know the standard of the requirement of assignments
the mean of this course is b- he said
but finally c+ i got
no idea why/.\

2014/15 Sem A

B

Very doubtful about how the grade is given, 'cause I he never marks on any assignment and the grade just popped out, very very disappointing..... didn't expect such low grade 'cause lots of effort was paid and he even praised me for many times, I mean, he never actually pointed out any problem when you consulting him, you just get the grade with no explanation, and he never replies emails, never.

Cautious to choose this course, even if u consider yourself to be good at photography, the judgement is too subjective.