跳至網頁內容

GE1337 Urban Green City: Pollution and Solution

評核項目
  • 不設考試
  • 設有小測
  • 設有個人報告
  • 設有小組研習
開辦學期
2017/18 Sem A 2016/17 Sem B 2016/17 Sem A 2015/16 Sem B 2015/16 Sem A 2014/15 Sem B 2014/15 Sem A 2013/14 Sem B
平均工作量
A+ (2)
A (2)
A- (4)
B+ (1)
B (0)
B- (1)
C+ (0)
C (0)
C- (0)
D (0)
Fail (0)
Dropped (0)

10 則留言 撰寫留言

2016/17 Sem B

B+

Assignment的分數沒有很大參考價值,
平常分超過90也未必在A-Range。
自問Project也是很用心做,應不會拖後腿,
最後只有這成績有點意料之外。

上課情況與前述留言情況差不多,不過沒有mid-term。

2016/17 Sem A

B-

呢科本應好grade,但自己問題
冇溫書,漏交&遲交assignment...

grade range好近,1%都好重要

mid term一定要溫書,佔final grade 30%
好似33題MC,即係1題約1%......
衰左的話都好難追。

workload都幾重
3份assignment同3份tutorial ws(佔25%,加埋都唔夠mid term多...)
3份800字assignment,唔難但都要嘥時間
3份tutorial ws上堂做,可以即堂交/之後交番

project都唔難做,presentation最後果個week
但report係sem break前1日交,
果陣大部份人都好早完左exam,有好多時間做。

2016/17 Sem A

A

首先講下平時課堂情況:
Professor份人幾好,幾關心學生,佢好樂意同好有耐性咁解答學生對課堂同group project嘅問題,更加會俾有用嘅建議/方向你去做

平時上堂唔take attendance,就算上堂遲到一粒鐘都冇乜所謂,上堂期間玩手機都冇乜野

上堂ok悶,雖然係上三粒鐘堂但係佢每堂上到一半就放大概半粒鐘Break,通常放Break前會教哂是日大部分學嘅嘢,而Break後一齊做tutorial/玩Pollution Game (佢自創嘅board game)/Project Consultation都得,有幾次早半粒鐘落堂

自問除左Group Project比較chur之外(得1-2個禮拜時間左右俾你去做成個PowerPoint),平時呢個course冇用到我太多時間,所以唔覺workload太重

以下係成個Course每part佔分比例:
3 Assignments (+ Tutorials = 25%):
Assignments 都係寫三頁essays,要跟足佢homework guidelines上嘅format,唔係就有機會你嗰一份essay扣5分,而最後一份essay題目可以自己揀(每個project group任意喺Pollution Game入面自選一條問題)

3 Tutorials:
三份tutorials都係上堂派俾你做,佢仲會抽少少上堂時間(即係break之後嘅時間)同大家discuss份嘢應該點做,有時仲會講埋答案,所以想攞滿分就唔建議走堂/早走(佢唔介意有學生趁Break期間走)

1 Mid-term Quiz (30%):
全32題MC,自問冇特別花太多時間去睇Lectures,但係基本上題目唔算難,有D仲要係送分(有chem底比較有著數)

1 Field Trip Report (2.5%):
雖然話係Report,但實際上係一份worksheet問你對Field Trip arrangement有咩feedback,有交Report會直接俾滿分(即係10/10)

1 Group Project (Presentation + Report) (40%):
Project主要係做sampling同分析數據,每組有特定研究方向,不過professor唔介意你做埋其他方向同分析,總之要喺15 mins presentation(+ Q&A session 5 mins)內講得晒就得
至於Report有7版限制,基本上係你成個presentation嘅文字版本,不過分析方面要詳細DD同加其他額外內容(要睇番佢對Report嘅要求),report format同樣要跟足佢嘅指引

Participation (2.5%):
因為佢冇take attendance習慣,所以唔多清楚點俾分

I'm actually belong to the same project group from whoever says "better find a groupmate who is good at generating graph and doing analysis" in another comment written here earlier =]

2016/17 Sem A

A-

He is a very good tutor. You can ask him any questions and he will answer all of them. Each lesson, he will spend around 1.5-2 hr to teach his notes (~80 pages). Then he will give a 20 mins break and start the tutorial section( WS/Game/Project consultation).

-Only 3-4 reflective essays(Assignment).
-He will not take the attendance
-A midterm(MC)
-A project(Better find a group mate who is good at generating graphs and doing the analysis)
-Project presentation and report(Max 7 pages)
-Workload is not too heavy
-A field trip report(Just hand in on time-->10/10)

2015/16 Sem B

A-

3 Assignments (30%)
- 最後做左2份,每份預3-4個鐘完成
Quiz (20%)
- open book; 如果有溫note同mark位, 就ok易
Participation (10%)
- ???
Group project (40%)
- 15% preset (個人計分) : 無咩特別
- 25% report (group計分) : 夠哂時間做, 唔算難
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
上堂係悶左少少,差唔多每堂都有project consultation (有野就問喇)
呀sir真係用心教書,用心答你問題
呢科有努力有回報

2015/16 Sem B

A-

Syllabus:
3 Assignments (30%)
"Mid" term Quiz (20%)
Participation (10%)
Term group project (40%)
1. Report (25% as group)
2. Presentation (15% as individual)

話就話三份individual assignments, 最後得兩份
上堂OK悶, 分咗project topic 之後會係咁同不同group consult
因為咁搞到教唔唒書

Individual Assignment:
類似EXAM 的essay type question, 5條一份, 通常有page limit (2-3 pages)
大部份notes有, 冇就自己wiki, mean幾高下 (>=90 each)
注意: 有數計, 不過幾易下

Quiz
Open book 5題 long q, not mc
有計數, 有抄野題, 有畫圖, 有吹水題
好伏, OPEN book 都冇咩用, 一係得keywords, 一係直頭唔係notes入面
自問做到DLLM, 不過唔會肥你, 最緊要有寫字唔好空咗佢

Project report& present
其實最易做, 個個WK 都consult, 有prepare 同跟comment 改唔會差得去邊
其實 report 10幾頁就OK

2015/16 Sem B

A-

Syllabus:
3 Assignments and 1 report (30%)
Final in week 12 (20%)
Participation (10%) <---利申唔知咩嚟
Term group project (40%)
1. Report (25% as group)
2. Presentation (15% as individual)

Notes slides 我數過有成700幾800頁 (9 topics)
每個topics成100頁slides
又多字又多圖又equations 你唔會想睇落去

突擊take attendance咗一次
但係因為每班得40個人 個classroom又細 Professor好易認得出邊個冇番

1個Assignment(5 LQs) 做2-3頁倒 (total 3 assignments)
合格易高分難果種feel (因為個mean都幾高下)

Final今次乞倒Professor open book
結果就GG
雖然有講大概final個range
但係因為因為真係太多notes 同notes根本no direct answers
(Open book根本係個伏嚟)
要真係用自己個豬腦去諗
上年明明係MC 今年變咗5 LQs
仲要有計數 條數有啲深度

Present 佢given咗topics
有啲topics都幾難做
just like Ship emissions , future electric vehicle 等等
講25mins (including Q&A)

Report就照番present咁做
寫20頁左右 不過要有深度同Critical thinking

個professor又真係幾好人嘅
不過呢個GE真係幾chur下
要做好多嘢又要高分先有番個靚grade
我今個sem讀第二個GE hea下hea下 冇咩點聽過書 交咗好少嘢 最後都係A-
對環保有興趣嘅 真係學倒嘢嘅 不過GE就算數啦
睇你鐘意chur定點 呢啲見人見知
呢個GE幾多嘢做同no standard answer 比分都幾主觀下

2015/16 Sem B

A+

Dr.Ning is a very good person, outline has been consulted for almost 5 weeks, work hard on project and quiz, need not to jot notes though as all in notes already, exam wish u good luck as this year not MC anymore (getting much more difficult)

2013/14 Sem B

A+

新開科, tutor俾分好鬆手, 所以個range好窄

幾大workload, 比較麻煩.

1. 4份assignments (30%)
每篇800字到, 佔分小. tutor自己create 左個game for我地上堂玩, 題目係自己group由個game到揀出來. 題目format係佢會定一個situation然後俾3-4個choices你, 要你分析返每個choice pros and cons, 揀一個你認為最好ge choice再俾原因. 其實靠common sense做都得, 我自己冇睇過notes, 每份都85-95%

2. 1份field report (5%)
有2個地方俾你揀 - lab / recycling centre. 去完之後寫返幾百字report, hea做都ok

3, pop-up quizzes (5%)
做過2次, 其實唔叫quiz, 因為tutor會一齊同你discuss份野, 係睇你留唔留心佢講ge野, 照寫返落去就ok.

4. mid-term test (20%)
全mc, 其實唔難, 好straight forward (不過lecture內容太多) 當中有幾題佢用來fake人, 所以份卷有40幾題但佢只係除返40做滿分 (個mean好似得around 70%)

5, group project (40%)
佔分好重, 分左presentation 同 report.
tutor自己定左題目再random分俾每一組 - 主要要就個topic去講返technology, economic aspect, policy implementation, social acceptability (抽2-3個)呢幾個aspects就ok, 但佢 ge guidelines其實幾唔清楚. 當然可以問佢, 佢都會教你應該著重講邊d aspects會好d
presentation同report內容一樣, 只係睇你ge skills
(tutor俾presentation ge comments 唔太好, 但total出黎都有>90%所以都幾出奇)

p.s. 每堂一份lecture notes, 平均70-80 slides都幾多幾誇張, tutor英文唔太好, 講野悶, 唔聽都得. 佢唔會take attendance, 不過pop-up quiz係會突然間有.