跳至網頁內容

GE1337 Urban Green City: Pollution and Solution

評核項目
  • 不設考試
  • 設有小測
  • 設有個人報告
  • 設有小組研習
開辦學期
2018/19 Sem A 2017/18 Sem A 2016/17 Sem B 2016/17 Sem A 2015/16 Sem B 2015/16 Sem A 2014/15 Sem B 2014/15 Sem A 2013/14 Sem B
平均工作量
A+ (2)
A (4)
A- (5)
B+ (4)
B (2)
B- (1)
C+ (0)
C (0)
C- (0)
D (0)
Fail (0)
Dropped (0)

18 則留言 撰寫留言

2018/19 Sem A

B

Rewarding experience given by an experienced and nice professor, the lectures consist of multidisciplinary materials ranging from chemistry, economics, physics to history. The course provides an introductory yet deep overview and analysis to the status quo of the energy, pollution and environmental issues. In terms of learning, if you find yourself interested in the environmental issues and would like to get a decent grade this course is a good choice.

Had good teammates but did not do well on my exam that's why I only got B

2018/19 Sem A

B+

每堂都有啲簡單activity,要tick attendance ,
但整體workload唔多,有兩份take home worksheet,一份poster group project同一個exam。
內容都算易follow, Peter講嘢唔算悶

2018/19 Sem A

B+

Peter is a good tutor, he very nice,before exam he give a mock exam paper and two tutor class for exam,both of them is useful,can help us to know the concept.We can bring the cheat sheet into the exam.The exam require little bit calculation but is easy,not to much difficult

The two take home assignment on week 4&8,we can discuss with other classmate and just do some research on internet,then can finish.

The poster is to choose one country and mention the pollution problem in that country,provide the solution to solve the problem,the poster which is group project and is hand-made,so it require some art skills,but is easy and also have example to follow.

Compare to other GE,it more relate to our daily life,most of information just a common sense,not too much difficult to follow

2018/19 Sem A

A-

Take home task 可以幾個人一齊做 易高分
Poster 又唔係好難做 有唔明嘅地方Peter 都幫我地解答 要Hand-made 但係剪剪貼貼好簡單
Exam俾帶A4 cheat sheet 不過寫cheat sheet 會辛苦d 有好多ppt 要mark 重點唔係好夠位
唔洗有Chem底 wordload 又唔重 真心推薦

2017/18 Sem A

B

有一個quiz 全部mc 有溫lecture notes就得 問啲野都幾淺白
有三份essay 都幾hea 吹下水
有group project (present+report) professor 幾好人 都算鬆手
上堂有boardgames 玩
係咁走堂 連field trip都冇去
有B都算係咁

2017/18 Sem A

A

3 tutorial assignment:
內容比較簡單,professor 都會同你討論埋答案,多數可以即堂交。

3 assignment:
3頁紙以內,回應返professor自製board game裡面嘅問題,1.5 spacing 12 time new roman。 我寫咗頗多,3份都800字度。順帶一提assignment係TA改嘅,俾分都算鬆手。

以上2項加埋25%

1 Mid-term Quiz: (30%)
40 MC 有science底就都幾輕鬆,都唔需要話温得好詳細。

1 Field Trip Report: (2.5%)
參觀咗個有機回收場,做返佢俾嗰份工作紙,有交就滿分。

2 Pop-up Quiz: (2.5%)
就係通常係最尾嗰幾堂,因為已經俾晒tutorial questions同 assignment questions,所以就會有pop-up quiz,其實就係一張紙仔,填返可能呢堂個topic係咩,有返就輕鬆答。我嗰陣miss咗一個,因為走咗堂。

1 Group Project:(40%)
最尾一個禮拜,有oral present同report要交。唔好揾豬隊友就ok,佢都俾得幾鬆手。

呢科workload非常多,一定要交齊。

2016/17 Sem B

B+

Assignment的分數沒有很大參考價值,
平常分超過90也未必在A-Range。
自問Project也是很用心做,應不會拖後腿,
最後只有這成績有點意料之外。

上課情況與前述留言情況差不多,不過沒有mid-term。

2016/17 Sem A

B-

呢科本應好grade,但自己問題
冇溫書,漏交&遲交assignment...

grade range好近,1%都好重要

mid term一定要溫書,佔final grade 30%
好似33題MC,即係1題約1%......
衰左的話都好難追。

workload都幾重
3份assignment同3份tutorial ws(佔25%,加埋都唔夠mid term多...)
3份800字assignment,唔難但都要嘥時間
3份tutorial ws上堂做,可以即堂交/之後交番

project都唔難做,presentation最後果個week
但report係sem break前1日交,
果陣大部份人都好早完左exam,有好多時間做。

2016/17 Sem A

A

首先講下平時課堂情況:
Professor份人幾好,幾關心學生,佢好樂意同好有耐性咁解答學生對課堂同group project嘅問題,更加會俾有用嘅建議/方向你去做

平時上堂唔take attendance,就算上堂遲到一粒鐘都冇乜所謂,上堂期間玩手機都冇乜野

上堂ok悶,雖然係上三粒鐘堂但係佢每堂上到一半就放大概半粒鐘Break,通常放Break前會教哂是日大部分學嘅嘢,而Break後一齊做tutorial/玩Pollution Game (佢自創嘅board game)/Project Consultation都得,有幾次早半粒鐘落堂

自問除左Group Project比較chur之外(得1-2個禮拜時間左右俾你去做成個PowerPoint),平時呢個course冇用到我太多時間,所以唔覺workload太重

以下係成個Course每part佔分比例:
3 Assignments (+ Tutorials = 25%):
Assignments 都係寫三頁essays,要跟足佢homework guidelines上嘅format,唔係就有機會你嗰一份essay扣5分,而最後一份essay題目可以自己揀(每個project group任意喺Pollution Game入面自選一條問題)

3 Tutorials:
三份tutorials都係上堂派俾你做,佢仲會抽少少上堂時間(即係break之後嘅時間)同大家discuss份嘢應該點做,有時仲會講埋答案,所以想攞滿分就唔建議走堂/早走(佢唔介意有學生趁Break期間走)

1 Mid-term Quiz (30%):
全32題MC,自問冇特別花太多時間去睇Lectures,但係基本上題目唔算難,有D仲要係送分(有chem底比較有著數)

1 Field Trip Report (2.5%):
雖然話係Report,但實際上係一份worksheet問你對Field Trip arrangement有咩feedback,有交Report會直接俾滿分(即係10/10)

1 Group Project (Presentation + Report) (40%):
Project主要係做sampling同分析數據,每組有特定研究方向,不過professor唔介意你做埋其他方向同分析,總之要喺15 mins presentation(+ Q&A session 5 mins)內講得晒就得
至於Report有7版限制,基本上係你成個presentation嘅文字版本,不過分析方面要詳細DD同加其他額外內容(要睇番佢對Report嘅要求),report format同樣要跟足佢嘅指引

Participation (2.5%):
因為佢冇take attendance習慣,所以唔多清楚點俾分

I'm actually belong to the same project group from whoever says "better find a groupmate who is good at generating graph and doing analysis" in another comment written here earlier =]

2016/17 Sem A

A-

He is a very good tutor. You can ask him any questions and he will answer all of them. Each lesson, he will spend around 1.5-2 hr to teach his notes (~80 pages). Then he will give a 20 mins break and start the tutorial section( WS/Game/Project consultation).

-Only 3-4 reflective essays(Assignment).
-He will not take the attendance
-A midterm(MC)
-A project(Better find a group mate who is good at generating graphs and doing the analysis)
-Project presentation and report(Max 7 pages)
-Workload is not too heavy
-A field trip report(Just hand in on time-->10/10)

2015/16 Sem B

A-

3 Assignments (30%)
- 最後做左2份,每份預3-4個鐘完成
Quiz (20%)
- open book; 如果有溫note同mark位, 就ok易
Participation (10%)
- ???
Group project (40%)
- 15% preset (個人計分) : 無咩特別
- 25% report (group計分) : 夠哂時間做, 唔算難
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
上堂係悶左少少,差唔多每堂都有project consultation (有野就問喇)
呀sir真係用心教書,用心答你問題
呢科有努力有回報

2015/16 Sem B

A-

Syllabus:
3 Assignments (30%)
"Mid" term Quiz (20%)
Participation (10%)
Term group project (40%)
1. Report (25% as group)
2. Presentation (15% as individual)

話就話三份individual assignments, 最後得兩份
上堂OK悶, 分咗project topic 之後會係咁同不同group consult
因為咁搞到教唔唒書

Individual Assignment:
類似EXAM 的essay type question, 5條一份, 通常有page limit (2-3 pages)
大部份notes有, 冇就自己wiki, mean幾高下 (>=90 each)
注意: 有數計, 不過幾易下

Quiz
Open book 5題 long q, not mc
有計數, 有抄野題, 有畫圖, 有吹水題
好伏, OPEN book 都冇咩用, 一係得keywords, 一係直頭唔係notes入面
自問做到DLLM, 不過唔會肥你, 最緊要有寫字唔好空咗佢

Project report& present
其實最易做, 個個WK 都consult, 有prepare 同跟comment 改唔會差得去邊
其實 report 10幾頁就OK

2015/16 Sem B

A-

Syllabus:
3 Assignments and 1 report (30%)
Final in week 12 (20%)
Participation (10%) <---利申唔知咩嚟
Term group project (40%)
1. Report (25% as group)
2. Presentation (15% as individual)

Notes slides 我數過有成700幾800頁 (9 topics)
每個topics成100頁slides
又多字又多圖又equations 你唔會想睇落去

突擊take attendance咗一次
但係因為每班得40個人 個classroom又細 Professor好易認得出邊個冇番

1個Assignment(5 LQs) 做2-3頁倒 (total 3 assignments)
合格易高分難果種feel (因為個mean都幾高下)

Final今次乞倒Professor open book
結果就GG
雖然有講大概final個range
但係因為因為真係太多notes 同notes根本no direct answers
(Open book根本係個伏嚟)
要真係用自己個豬腦去諗
上年明明係MC 今年變咗5 LQs
仲要有計數 條數有啲深度

Present 佢given咗topics
有啲topics都幾難做
just like Ship emissions , future electric vehicle 等等
講25mins (including Q&A)

Report就照番present咁做
寫20頁左右 不過要有深度同Critical thinking

個professor又真係幾好人嘅
不過呢個GE真係幾chur下
要做好多嘢又要高分先有番個靚grade
我今個sem讀第二個GE hea下hea下 冇咩點聽過書 交咗好少嘢 最後都係A-
對環保有興趣嘅 真係學倒嘢嘅 不過GE就算數啦
睇你鐘意chur定點 呢啲見人見知
呢個GE幾多嘢做同no standard answer 比分都幾主觀下

2015/16 Sem B

A+

Dr.Ning is a very good person, outline has been consulted for almost 5 weeks, work hard on project and quiz, need not to jot notes though as all in notes already, exam wish u good luck as this year not MC anymore (getting much more difficult)

2013/14 Sem B

A+

新開科, tutor俾分好鬆手, 所以個range好窄

幾大workload, 比較麻煩.

1. 4份assignments (30%)
每篇800字到, 佔分小. tutor自己create 左個game for我地上堂玩, 題目係自己group由個game到揀出來. 題目format係佢會定一個situation然後俾3-4個choices你, 要你分析返每個choice pros and cons, 揀一個你認為最好ge choice再俾原因. 其實靠common sense做都得, 我自己冇睇過notes, 每份都85-95%

2. 1份field report (5%)
有2個地方俾你揀 - lab / recycling centre. 去完之後寫返幾百字report, hea做都ok

3, pop-up quizzes (5%)
做過2次, 其實唔叫quiz, 因為tutor會一齊同你discuss份野, 係睇你留唔留心佢講ge野, 照寫返落去就ok.

4. mid-term test (20%)
全mc, 其實唔難, 好straight forward (不過lecture內容太多) 當中有幾題佢用來fake人, 所以份卷有40幾題但佢只係除返40做滿分 (個mean好似得around 70%)

5, group project (40%)
佔分好重, 分左presentation 同 report.
tutor自己定左題目再random分俾每一組 - 主要要就個topic去講返technology, economic aspect, policy implementation, social acceptability (抽2-3個)呢幾個aspects就ok, 但佢 ge guidelines其實幾唔清楚. 當然可以問佢, 佢都會教你應該著重講邊d aspects會好d
presentation同report內容一樣, 只係睇你ge skills
(tutor俾presentation ge comments 唔太好, 但total出黎都有>90%所以都幾出奇)

p.s. 每堂一份lecture notes, 平均70-80 slides都幾多幾誇張, tutor英文唔太好, 講野悶, 唔聽都得. 佢唔會take attendance, 不過pop-up quiz係會突然間有.