跳至網頁內容

GE2119 Passion for Books: Reading and Publishing in Greater China 讓我們好好愛上閱讀:兩岸三地的華文出版、閱讀生態

評核項目
  • 不設考試
  • 設有小測
  • 設有個人報告
  • 設有小組研習
開辦學期
2013/14 Sem A 2012/13 Sem B 2012/13 Sem A
平均工作量
A+ (0)
A (0)
A- (1)
B+ (0)
B (2)
B- (1)
C+ (0)
C (0)
C- (0)
D (1)
Fail (0)
Dropped (0)

5 則留言 撰寫留言

2013/14 Sem A

A-

我覺得馬sir本身係有料到,上堂聽佢講就好比聽緊talk show...唔悶,佢講野幾有趣的。會成日叫我地反思(political又有,乜都有)。
Workload方面好見人見智…你有心做佢個project嘿individual paper自然會發好多時間去研讀你個present本書。事前你仲可以consult佢,佢甚至會借相關書俾你,重點係你有無心同問佢。

Individual paper佢已經讓步俾我地做返presentation本書。同樣的,可私下搵佢consult同借書。不過都係,你無prepare過,做好research去搵佢,只會俾佢串到你飛起。(不過我都明,浪費人時間呢一點lol)

我個人individual paper同presentation做同一本書唔同perspective,不過除gp present外無consult佢,自認文筆唔太好。為左補償返我d差文筆,我爆字咁寫…我相信afford佢見到的,結果俾左A range我我真心想喊...

我覺得呢堂上得過。因為其他GE大部份都係聽個tutor吹,why not聽一個有趣d ge lecture?你有乜想知又可以free discussion時問馬sir,project搵人consult佢係有求就會應,仲肯私下借書做reference(重點係佢選好幾本俾你個gp)...
不過聽聞佢去教MA同cciv,未必教呢科了 :(

2013/14 Sem A

B

課的內容不錯,可以理解為馬家輝的現場鏘鏘三人行……啊……雖然遠遠不止三個人……

作業不多也不難。基本上只要擔心present的那個小組裡有沒有豬隊友就行了……
多和馬家輝互動還能加分,聽完別人的present然後找對方茬問他們問題也能加分,不過就算如此我最後分數也只有B……有點失望啊……

話說馬家輝經常會送大家書或者雜誌,如果是他自己出的書還有簽名,真好啊……【可惜我只拿到一本雜誌QAQ

PS
沒有歧視的意思,但是可以的話上了莊的同學請三思……因為一旦要競選要sit con的話……呃……就不一定能好好做組隊作業了……畢竟要讀完一本書並且抽出一部分內容來present的話還是需要精力和時間的……

2013/14 Sem A

D

There are only two assignments and a group project. Both assignments are essays which seem to be easy. The word amount is not a lot but I believe you have to write much more to get an only B grade. The group project was indeed a very troublesome one which took me much time.
Overall, I was shocked to know that I got a D grade because I've done all the assignments. I deserve a better grade although I didn't put much effort. I think Ma Ka Fai is just too harsh. He's a completely different person after the class. You'll see when you discuss your group project with him.

2012/13 Sem B

B

基本上上堂都係聽佢吹水 冇野做 唔take attendence 唔番冇問題 不過平時要等人present果陣多啲舉手發問拎平時分 workload好少 present幾分鐘 係個final report佢個標題任你定 所以有啲捉唔到佢個評分準則 基本上好hea

2012/13 Sem A

B-

3個鐘lecture 冇tutorial 上堂唔take attendance
全部都係聽馬嘉輝吹水 佢咩都講一餐
week6定唔知week7 開始每堂都係睇人地present 馬嘉輝會吹一個鐘左右
所以其實全部唔返都冇咩損失 剩係返自己present果日就夠
workload唔多 一個project(5-6個人 30 min present)
一本book report(自己揀一本書) 同一份final essay (題目不限 同書有關就得)

成組都係b range
因為馬嘉輝係作家 所以好睇essay文筆 自問自己文筆mama地 有b- 都算係咁
同埋建議係人地組present果陣 多d係q&a section 問問題 會加分